by Dr Thomas Walford, Expert Evidence
Who does an expert witness owe a duty to?
This is probably the most important aspect of an expert’s work. His duty is to the court and he has to maintain his independence at all times. This has been enshrined in the court rules in many parts of the world.
An expert is someone who has succeeded in making decisions and judgements simpler through knowing what to pay attention to and what to ignore.”
Edward de Bono
Originally the duties of an expert were covered in a court case, which is now known as the Ikarian Reefer rules. This follows a judgement by Mr. Justice Cresswell in National Justice Compania Naviera SA v Prudential Assurance Company Limited in 1993.
Since then various legal jurisdictions have produced detailed rules such as:
English Civil – Civil Procedure Rules Part 35, Practice Direction 35 and the Protocol for the Instruction of Experts to give Evidence in Civil Claims and the Guidance for the instruction of experts in civil claims 2014.
English Criminal – Criminal Procedural Rules part 19.
Scotland – No formal rules but there is a Code of Practice and case law similar to Ikarian Reefer principles.
Northern Ireland – Codes of Practice for Experts PD 1/2015 , PD 7/2014 , PD 2/2009 & PD 6/2002. Please note that the expert declaration in 6/2002 has been replaced by 7/2014.
Jersey – Civil Evidence (Jersey) Law 2003 revised to 1 January 2013 and detail.
Guernsey – The Evidence in Civil Proceedings (Guernsey and Alderney) Rules 2011.
Switzerland – Article 272 of Swiss Civil Procedure Code.
Europe – Civil Litigation Guide (to be enacted) and published in 5 languages – Expert’s European Guide for Legal Expertise including Code of Conduct.
Council of Europe – Human Rights and Rule of Law – European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (‘CEPEJ’) – Guidelines on the role of court-appointed experts in judicial proceedings of Council of Europe’s Member States.
Australia – Practice Notes for the Federal Court.
Canada – Rule 53.03 Code of Conduct for Expert of the Federal Court Rules and The Advocates’ Society – Links to practice directions in all Canadian States for testifying experts.
Bermuda uses the Ikarian Reefer precedent,
Dubai International Financial Centre (‘DIFC’) Rules part 31 and Schedule A.
Hong Kong uses the Rules of the High Court precedent.
Singapore – Evidence Act – Opinions of third persons when relevant , Criminal Procedure Code – Report of qualified persons , Rules of the Court Order 40 and 40A,
US – Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 and also by Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 706.
There are also some places which still have no rules but then it is common to adopt the rules from a known jurisdiction usually the English ones. One such place is Ireland, which although has an established basis on which expert evidence is given, there are not formal rules. It is anticipated that they will institute their own before too long.
Please do not expect an expert to support the case irrespective of the facts, it will avoid disappointment. Although he will not be part of the legal team who is arguing for a litigation party – he is probably a real asset if he is used correctly.
Expert Evidence has a large international business and regularly is called to give evidence in courts around the world.
Ask a question about expert witness services. We are here to help!
Copyright of Expert Evidence 2018
This and other useful articles on instructing and acting as an expert witness are available from: http://expert-evidence.com/expert-witness/. Relevant legal cases can also be found on http://expert-evidence.com/resources/.
Dr Thomas Walford Expert Evidence Limited
Expert Evidence International Limited 36 Old Park Avenue London SW12 8RH Tel: +44 20 7884 1000 Mob: +44 7769 707020 www: expert-evidence.com